Blue Commonwealth Logo

Advanced Search
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Become a Supporter
Like Blue Commonwealth? Want to help keep it running?
Contribute Today, and help keep our blog ad free!




Blog Roll
7 West
Albo Must Go
Anonymous is a Woman
Anti-BVBL
Article XI
Assembly Access
Augusta Free Press
Bacon's Rebellion
Blacknell
Blue Ridge Data
Blue Virginia
Blueweeds
Byrne-ing Up the Internet
Central VA Progressive
ChangeServant
Coarse Cracked Corn
CobaltVA
CvilleDave
The Daily Dogwood
Dem Bones
DemocracyUpsideDown
DemRulz
Equality Loudoun
Fairfax City Dems
WaPo - The Fix
Fred2Blue
Getting Around
Great Blue Heron
The Green Miles
Heartland of Va
Leesburg Tomorrow
Left of the Hill
New Dominion Project
Not Larry Sabato
Ox Road South Blog
Penning Thoughts
Powhatan Democrats
Renaissance Ruminations
River City Rapids
Rule .303
RockDem
Shad Plank
Sisyphus
SlantBlog
Southeast Virginia
Star City Harbinger
Tokatakiya
Too Progressive
United States of Jamerica
VB Dems
VB Progressives
Virginia Dem
The Virginia Democrat
WaPo - Virginia Politics Blog
Vivian Paige
Waldo Jaquith
Waldo's VA Political Blogroll
xcurmudgeon

Virginia Primary Map: Creigh Sweeps from Clarendon to Coal Country

by: Patrick Ottenhoff

Wed Jun 10, 2009 at 11:45:29 AM EDT


(We thank Patrick for crossposting this here.  It shows the magnitude of the Deeds victory, and also makes clear his ability to run well anywhere in the state. - promoted by teacherken)

Cross-posted at The Electoral Map

In the first Democratic primary for Virginia governor in ages, the boy from Bath County embarrassed the two guys from NoVA.  Creigh Deeds won a strong 50% over Terry McAuliffe's 26% and Brian Moran's 24%.  What's striking is that he won ten out of 11 congressional districts, even beating Moran 43-40% in his brother's district, the 8th, and losing only the majority black 3rd, held by Rep. Bobby Scott, to Terry.

06 10 Virginia Governor Electoral Map

Patrick Ottenhoff :: Virginia Primary Map: Creigh Sweeps from Clarendon to Coal Country
A few interesting points:
  • Talk about a base - In Criegh's home county and three surrounding counties - Bath, Allegheny, Highland and Rockbridge - 4398 votes were cast. 4091 were for Creigh.  In all of Highland County, for example, Moran got only 3 votes while Creigh received over 1200.
  • Creigh won Clinton voters - Remember the Obama-Clinton map where Clinton won everywhere west of the Blue Ridge and Obama won the urban crescent? Well, it's clear that Creigh won many of those same Clinton voters.
  • Dissecting the Obama coalition - Creigh will have no problem winning the Prius drivers in  Arlington and Alexandria who are true blue Dems and lovingly supported Jim Webb despite some conservative views. What Creigh needs to worry about is the other leg of the Obama coalition - African-American voters in Richmond, Southside and Tidewater.
  • Terry won the black vote - Terry won a plurality in Bobby Scott's district that stretches from the Seven Cities up to east Richmond. I remember Terry's early ads were at the Newport News shipyard,  and he later visited Hampton with Will.i.am. He needed to do really well there, not just win a plurality.
  • Don't sleep on C'Ville - Charlottesville and Albemarle are major bastions of liberal Democratic votes. The fact that Creigh's state Senate seat covers these communities gave him a strong start in this crucial pocket.
  • The WaPo effect - Most armchair pundits think Creigh won because of his Washington Post endorsement. In reality, Creigh locked up downstate voters with cheap TV ads early and only contested NoVA once he got the endorsement. He wasn't scheduled to appear at the VA FREE lunch until he won the WaPo nod, and his signs cropped up virtually overnight up here.
  • A balanced ticket - Gov. Tim Kaine is likely happy about the geographic balance of the ticket - A Gov candidate from the hills, an LG candidate from the Beach, and an AG candidate from the NoVA burbs.  Republicans, for their part, also boast a balanced ticket with VA Beach, Richmond and Fairfax County all represented.
  • What about NoVA? - For the second gubernatorial election in a row, both parties elected candidates from outside NoVA.  So will the ad wars be fought in Roanoke, Richmond and Hampton Roads, or will they spend the big money in Washington?
  • The Clintons just don't play well in VA - Bill Clinton never won Virginia, despite taking a number of border states, including West Virginia  and Kentucky.  Hillary got smoked here. And Bill's right hand man Terry ultimately failed.  Maybe those Clinton robocalls hurt more than they helped?
  • The engine of VA - Virginia's economic success has a big part to do with the booms in Fairfax, Loudoun, Price William and Henrico counties - Creigh won all of these, just like Kaine did in the '05 general and Obama did in the '08 general.

So how will Creigh Deeds stack up against Bob McDonnell?  That's the subject of another post, but it's clear that the map is going to be dynamic and scrambled and that the battlegrounds will be constantly evolving.  NoVA, which accounts for one out of every seven votes in Virginia, is obviously the big prize, but Deeds will certainly try to make inroads in McDonnell's base in Hampton Roads and we can bet on McDonnell going for the F-150 Democrats in Creigh's neck of the woods.  Let the games begin.
Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Excellent Analysis!
What do you think Creigh will need to do to score big African American turnout for him?

Enfranchisement
One thing I was very glad to see this year was all candidates talking about reforming Virginia's overly restrictive laws prohibiting felons who have done their time and repaid their debt to society from voting. THAT is an issue which has some game, I think.

Not to mention the fact that it is just the right thing to do, period.


[ Parent ]
Second this
The fact is that our restrictive laws have a very discriminatory impact upon the African American community in particular.

While we're at it we really need to see Virginia take a good long look at Jim Webb's concerns about the incarceration crisis.  The General Assembly has been steadily expanding the definition of felonies for years.  The zero tolerance drug nonsense has got to go.  Right now, anyone in illicit possession of practically anything but marijuana is committing a felony no matter how small the amount.  Let's stop sending drug addicts and casual recreational drug users to prison and imposing felony convictions on people for what in other jurisdictions is considered a middling misdemeanor.  I'd love to see some action on this issue.


[ Parent ]
I would LOVE
to see Creigh make an announcement that, by executive order, every ex-felon that has completed his/her prison sentence will automatically be re-instated to the voter rolls, without having to apply to be reinstated.

(I had hoped Brian would make this kind of announcement, but ...)

If Creigh were to make a major push for voting rights like this, I think this would really help his standing in the African-American community going forward.  


[ Parent ]
I'm pretty certain that's the job of the general assembly
and no executive order has that scope of power.  But, they can and should push for it.

[ Parent ]
Washington Post and Yard Signs
The Washington Post endorsement was huge for the campaign because it made voters in Northern Virginia look at Creigh as a candidate since even in their own words, he wasn't he "obvious" choice he was the "right" choice.  I think given the amount of media attention that Terry and Brian really garnered in the months leading up to May made people think "Wow, if the Post endorsed a guy who lives closer to WV than DC then there must be some good stuff there."  I know I spoke to a lot of callers in my hundreds if not close to over 1,000 calls I've made and a lot of people took notice to the Post's endorsement.  I'm speaking from my personal experience with callers, so say what you want about the effect of the endorsement I can say it had a substantial affect.

Regarding the yard signs:  You are right, they virtually did just pop up overnight.  I actually thought that there were going to be substantially more McAuliffe and Moran signs in comparison to Deeds signs, especially knowing the I.A.F.F (Firefighters) have a solid game plan in that regard.  IF you remember around the time they popped up we were going through that long stretch of rain and nasty weather.  Team Deeds NoVa (As I've come to call it) put up most of the signs during that nasty weather and didn't let it affect wave of signs they wanted to put out.  The signs went up over a very short period and I can speak that the weather was horrible so I'm not sure if that affected other volunteers in not wanted to go out in the weather.  

Lastly, the McAuliffe campaign spoke of their vast volunteers leading up to election day.  I don't think many people know the size the Northern Virginia operation for Deeds outside of our group.  I won't disclose our exact number because no matter the size it got the job done, especially given the fact that Creigh handily won Northern Virginia!


What about NoVA
I don't think you need to wonder.  The battle will most certainly be fought here as well as in Hampton Roads and Richmond.  The three metro areas account for well over 50% of the votes cast in the 2008 and 2005 elections.  Fairfax's share of the vote is twice that of the next highest which is Virginia Beach City.  Stopping at Loudon and Prince William, NoVA's share of the vote was 27.7% of the vote in 2008 and 25.6% in 2005.  I fully expect that share to be even higher this year (even with low turn-out).  And just for further perspective, increasing your margin in Fairfax has 10 times the impact of increasing your margin by a similar percent in Albemarle County.  So, any statewide candidate would be a fool not to spend a good deal of time here.  

I can assure you Bob McDonnell will be spending a lot of time, money and effort in Loudon, Prince William and Fairfax.  And so Deeds will need to at a minimum match him.  

Now the media market here may be way expensive, but money is going to be pouring in from out of state.  The only other governor's race this year is New Jersey.  So, expect this to be a battle royale with Republicans firing up their big donor base in the Houston and Dallas zip codes.  And while major network media may be expensive here, the cable alternative is less so.  I know have seen Bob McDonnell ads on constant rotation on New Channel 8 (the local ABC affiliate's sister station).

And to be absolutely clear, winning Loudon and PW in the primaries is not the same as winning them in the general.  This will be a low turn-out year.  So, I worry that Loudon, PW, and Fairfax will be prime pick-up ground for the Republicans.  If nothing else, cutting the margin will do wonders for them.  See my example above to see that a small change in FFX can do a lot of damage.


No way in hell McDonnell will win in Northern Virginia
It's just not going to happen. The area is constantly growing more liberal.

[ Parent ]
But we shouldn't take anything for granted... n/t


"One person, one vote" died at the hands of SCOTUS, January 21, 2010

[ Parent ]
Darn right!
Nothing should be taken for granted this fall!  The Republicans want Virginia to be red again.  Now that all three camps can join as one I think we'll be unstoppable!  

Deeds, Wagner and Shannon Supporter!!!


[ Parent ]
My point is not that he will win them
If he only narrows the gap, that benefits him extraordinarily.  And as other people point out, I would not take the whole of Northern Virginia for granted.

What I think needs to be recognized is that Republicans also picked the best possible candidate they could put forward in the general.  Bob McDonnell will be a challenge.  He is not Kilgore.


[ Parent ]
Speaking AS Loudoun
Speaking as a precinct captain in Loudoun County - we are not going to let our side lose.

The thing about the past few years here is this: regardless of the candidate's presence, we have been building an army of canvassers and activists since the 2006 Webb campaign here. (Really, since David Poisson in 2005.) I for one have walked my precinct a few times in each election cycle for the past three years.

So yeah, we look forward to our candidates spending time here. That being said, their absence or presence isn't going to impact whether or not I put my hat on and knock doors each weekend.

I'm doing that anyway.


[ Parent ]
It'll be interesting to see
how the two campaigns (Deeds vs McDonnell) unfold; where each of them thinks his "Achilles heel" might be, and how they try to "bandage" it.

For Deeds, we have to balance:
1) west and south west is my natural base/stomping ground but rural/small town Va tends to be pro-Republican. Can I afford to assume that the support of the "native son" will prevail over what the preachers say, Sunday after Sunday? Especially in sparsely populated areas? What worked for the primary isn't likely to translate into the same results in general.

with:
2) NoVa is, exactly, "the other way around". It trends Democratic, and is more densely populated (more bang for the buck) but it's also more likely to assume I'm a hick who doesn't know or care about their concerns. How much effort and cash do I need to expend, to persuade them otherwise?

And then, of course, there is the rest of the state -- neither SoVa, nor NoVa, both urban and rural -- which will, probably, need a different approach still.

I don't know enough McDonnell to know what/where his solid base might be and where his weak points are but, I expect, they'll be somewhat similar. Neither one of them can take any part of the state for granted. But both, likely, will profit from as large -- and targeted -- a turnout as we can scramble up.


[ Parent ]
Shenandoah Valley could be decisive
looks to me as though it could shape up that way. I live on the border of Highland and Bath, work on the border of Rockingham.

Need to get the Obama Harrisonburg operation revved up again, sooner rather than later.


It sure did an awseome job in 2008
It (the Obama Harrionburg operation) sure did an awesome job in 2008.  500 folks at one event!  That's better than we did here in MOCO.  And we have Democratic representation here.

"One person, one vote" died at the hands of SCOTUS, January 21, 2010

[ Parent ]
It was magic Kathy
but, despite significant Democratic gains there, the other side have the Harry Byrd Jr. daily newspaper, the rural countryside and heavy representation in Congress and the state legislature.

I'll shortly e-mail all my old friends over there from this past fall, though I'm certain that's unnecessary.

I'm sure they're "Fired Up and Ready To Go."

(But it never hurts to add some extra fuel to the fire, either.)

:)


[ Parent ]
Recent Comments

Blue Commonwealth is a community forum for the discussion of political issues of interest to Virginians.
The opinions expressed by users of this website do not necessarily reflect the views of Blue Commonwealth or its editors.
Powered by: SoapBlox